I Don't Want to Talk About It — The CAT's 2012 Cover and the Heartbreaking Story of Danny Whitten

Some songs hit you the first time. Some songs hit you harder once you know who wrote them.


"I Don't Want to Talk About It" is one of the second kind.


How I Learned It: My Mom's Song

Before I knew anything about this song, what it was about, who originally wrote it, I knew it simply because my parents used to own several nightclubs in Taiwan when I was a child and this was one of the songs my mom would hum to me. She didn't know what the fuck it was about either, but she knew the chorus and the tune, and that's how and why I learned it at first.


And growing up in an abusive and oppressive Chinese family, the main line of this song rang out loud and true in my heart even if I didn't know anything else about the song: "I don't want to talk about it!" was literally the answer me and my family members would give to any kind-hearted strangers who inquired "what's wrong?"


So you see, rather than just a popular tune, this song was literally a phrase from my heart for many years.


On September 23, 2012, less than a week after my very first upload, I uploaded The CAT's cover of it. Three and a half minutes, no talking, just the song. In the description I called it a Rod Stewart song, because that's the version everybody knows. But Rod didn't write it. And the guy who did has one of the saddest stories in rock music.


So before you press play, let me tell you about him.


The CAT Days

Quick refresher if you're new here. Back in 2012 I was Tiger, one half of The CAT, short for Cheetah and Tiger. Cheetah was Liz Wade, on clarinet and sax, and she sang with me too. We were based here in Richmond, and we did a mix of my originals and covers.


This one was a cover. In the original description I wrote that "the instrumental and vocal are new", meaning we built our own backing track and recorded our own vocals, not karaoke over somebody else's music. I also said it was "yet unseen on any CAT album." Back then our albums were up on CD Baby, and this track wasn't on any of them. YouTube was where it lived.


So yeah, 73 views in fourteen years. Not exactly a chart topper LOL. But it deserves a bit of a story.


Danny Whitten: The Man Who Wrote It

The song was written by an American guitarist named Danny Whitten. He was born in Columbus, Georgia, in 1943, and he played in a band called The Rockets with Billy Talbot and Ralph Molina.


Then Neil Young started jamming with them. Neil took those three, and they became Crazy Horse, his backing band. That's Danny singing with Neil on "Cinnamon Girl", and trading guitar with him on "Down by the River" and "Cowgirl in the Sand" on Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere in 1969.


In 1971, Crazy Horse put out their own self-titled album, without Neil fronting it. "I Don't Want to Talk About It" is on there, the last track on side one, with Danny singing lead. Nils Lofgren is on guitar and backing vocals, and Ry Cooder plays slide. Not a bad lineup for a song most people think belongs to somebody else.


Here's the part that gets me.


Danny suffered from rheumatoid arthritis. He found that heroin dulled the pain, and he got hooked. Fast. Neil Young wrote "The Needle and the Damage Done" about what he was watching happen to his friend.


Anybody who has read my sage oil and Tiger Balm post on this blog knows I don't judge people for chasing relief. Pain makes you desperate. But that drug took everything from him.


On November 18, 1972, Neil sent him home from rehearsals for the Harvest tour because he just couldn't keep up. That same night, Danny died. He was 29.


Neil said years later that he felt responsible for a long time. And the song Danny left behind, the one he was best known for, is a guy begging someone to stay a little longer and listen to his heart. Damn.


How Rod Stewart Made It Famous

Rod Stewart recorded his version at Muscle Shoals Sound Studio in Sheffield, Alabama, for his 1975 album Atlantic Crossing.


Image: A low, single-storey building faced with grey stacked stone under a clear blue sky. A long blue sign with white lettering across the front reads "3614 JACKSON HIGHWAY". Two curtained windows sit on either side of a recessed doorway, and a red-and-white sign by the door reads "Muscle Shoals Sound Studios OPEN TODAY". The side wall is painted tan, with another blue sign reading "Muscle Shoals SOUND STUDIOS". A string of small light bulbs runs along the roofline, and there is a gravel path and patchy grass in front.

[


]


That little stone building at 3614 Jackson Highway is where a crazy number of hits got made in the late 60s and 70s, by the Rolling Stones, Paul Simon, Bob Seger and a ton of others, with the house band people call the Swampers.


When Rod's version came out as a single in the UK in 1977, it went to number one as a double A-side with "The First Cut Is the Deepest". And there's a famous story that comes with it. That was the summer of the Queen's Silver Jubilee, and the Sex Pistols had "God Save the Queen" out. A lot of people believe Rod's single was kept at the top, partly by being sold cheap, to keep the punks off number one. Whether that's the whole truth or not, it's a hell of a piece of music history. A dead songwriter's ballad blocking the Sex Pistols.


Image: A black-and-white concert photo of Rod Stewart in 1976. He has a shaggy, layered rock haircut and is smiling as he sings into a microphone on a stand, holding the stand with one hand. He wears a loose white shirt with puffed sleeves and dark lace trim around the upper arms, open at the chest with a thin chain necklace, and a wide studded belt. The background is dark and plain.

[


]


That's Rod in Oslo, Norway, in November 1976, right around this era.


Rod kept coming back to the song, too. He cut a new version in 1989 for his Storyteller anthology, and that one went to number two on the Billboard Adult Contemporary chart in the US. He also sang it as a duet with Amy Belle on his 2004 tour, and that live video has passed a billion views on YouTube. A billion. Compared to our 73. Hmmmm.


And it's not just Rod. In 1988 Everything but the Girl, another duo, put out their version and got to number three in the UK. Tracey Thorn said she grew up in a house where Rod Stewart was a hero, and she always liked Atlantic Crossing. That one makes me smile a bit, a duo covering it, because that's exactly what Cheetah and I were.


Why Do a Cover at All?

People sometimes ask why a songwriter bothers with covers. I write my own stuff. Why sing somebody else's?


Because a song like this is a lesson. It's simple. A few lines, one big chorus, and all the weight sits in how you sing it. You can't hide behind anything. Danny Whitten wrote it, Rod Stewart made it huge, Everything but the Girl made it soft and sad, and every bar band on the planet has had a go at it.


Our version is just one more in that long line. A little lo-fi, very 2012, done the way The CAT did everything, building the track ourselves.


And honestly, knowing what I know now about Danny, I hear the song differently. It's not just a breakup tune anymore. It's the best thing a guy in a lot of pain left behind.


Watch The CAT's 2012 cover here:



Disclaimer, same as on the video: this is not our original song. It belongs to its rights holders. We just love it.


Photo credits: Muscle Shoals Sound Studio exterior by A1bi, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Rod Stewart, Oslo 1976, by Helge Øverås, CC BY 2.5, via Wikimedia Commons.


---


To learn more about my work as an artist, musician, martial artist, and advocate, visit johnnytiger.com.


To explore my tactile artwork and accessibility-focused creative projects, visit tigertactile.com.


#IDontWantToTalkAboutIt #DannyWhitten #RodStewart #CrazyHorse #EverythingButTheGirl #MuscleShoals #CoverSong #TheCAT #CheetahAndTiger #LizTheCheetah #MusicHistory #BlindMusician #CanadianArtist #RichmondBC #SingerSongwriter #MusicBlog #2012 #JohnnyTiger #JohnnyTigerExperience #TigerTactile #BlindArtist

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

🐍 Mythic Legions Ninian Infantry: Snake Year, Snake Power, Snake Love 🐍

The Great Cthulhu Figure – A Nightmare You’ll Love to Touch (and Curse)

The Feng Shui War That Shook Hong Kong’s Skyline